From The Oklahoman, December 29, 2010
Oklahoma Gov. Brad Henry will review the three nominees from the Oklahoma Judicial Nominating Commission. If he is to make his sixth appointment to the high court, he must act before noon Jan. 10.
Lt. Gov. Jari Askins, a state civil appellate judge and an Oklahoma County district judge are the three nominees to fill the vacancy on the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
The Oklahoma Judicial Nominating Commission submitted the nominees Tuesday to Gov. Brad Henry after a daylong session of interviewing 14 finalists.
In addition to Askins, the nominees are Judge John Fischer, of Oklahoma City, whom Henry appointed to the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals, and Oklahoma County District Judge Noma Gurich, of Oklahoma City.
A new Supreme Court justice is needed to succeed Marian Opala, who died Oct. 11.
Askins, a Democrat, applied for the vacancy by the Nov. 19 deadline, which was less than three weeks after she lost the Nov. 2 gubernatorial election to Republican Mary Fallin. She said then the timing was awkward, but she felt it was an opportunity to continue in public service.
Two legal challenges to the authority of the commission to make the recommendation are pending with the state Supreme Court. The commission's action makes moot a request to ask the high court to issue an order to delay the process.
Henry said he would like to appoint a successor before he leaves office and urged the commission to act quickly. Nineteen applied for the post, and the commission reduced the list to 14.
It asked the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation to conduct background checks on them and then interviewed the finalists Tuesday.
Henry's term ends at noon Jan. 10. He likely will continue his practice of meeting and talking with each of the nominees before making his selection.
Henry during his nearly eight years in office has named five justices to the nine-member high court. Naming Opala's successor would mean the Democratic governor appointed two-thirds of the justices, a rare opportunity. Former Gov. George Nigh, who also served back-to-back terms, appointed three.
If Henry doesn't fill the vacancy, the names would be forwarded to Fallin.
Henry appointed Fischer, 62, to the state Court of Civil Appeals in 2006. Fischer served as an assistant attorney general in Oklahoma from 1976 to 1980 and was in private practice from 1980 to 2006.
Gurich, 58, was unopposed and won re-election to a four-year term this year. She has been an Oklahoma County district judge since 1998.
She won a contested election in 1998 and was re-elected without opposition in 2002, 2006 and this year.
Askins, 57, was appointed a Stephens County special judge in 1982 and served eight years on the bench. She was elected in 1994 to the House of Representatives. She was elected lieutenant governor in 2006 and opted to run for governor instead of seeking re-election. She defeated outgoing Attorney General Drew Edmondson in the Democratic primary.
Legal challenges
One challenge filed with the Supreme Court claims the Judicial Nominating Commission shouldn't take any action until its membership complies fully with provisions of a state ballot measure voters approved last month.
State Question 752, which was approved by 63 percent of those voting, requires the appointment of two more nonlawyers to the commission — increasing its size from 13 members to 15 members. The ballot measure became effective when election results were certified a week later.
The speaker of the House and president pro tem of the Senate, both Republicans, are each to make one of the new appointments. Neither has made an appointment.
The state question also says none of the nonlawyer commission members appointed by the governor can have lawyers in their immediate families.
That led three members to resign in November, and Henry since has named three successors.
A lawsuit alleges the Judicial Nominating Commission is unconstitutional because its membership is based on six congressional districts, rather than the five the state has.
Henry's critics especially were concerned that one of the applicants for the post was Robert D. Bell, of Oklahoma City, whom the governor in 2005 named to the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals. Bell's uncle is Richard Bell, a Henry family friend who also is chairman of the Sarkeys Foundation, which last year hired Henry's wife as its executive director.
No comments:
Post a Comment