The tragic shooting rampage at the Arizona Congressional event held by Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, which has left the Congresswoman in serious and uncertain condition and six, including a nine-year old girl, a federal judge, and a House staffer dead; has raised a debate about the current state of American political rhetoric.
Earlier this year, the Congresswoman had had her office vandalized after her vote in support of President Obama's health care reform bill, which raised the ire of conservative activists. At the time Giffords went on MSNBC to state that people need to realize "that the rhetoric and firing people up [...] there's consequences to that action." Arizona has been a politically tense state ever since state legislators passed a bill allowing for police officers to request proof of legal residency as part of a measure against illegal immigration. The law was condemned as official racial profiling by many critics. In a press conference held after the shooting, Tuscon's mayor stated that "We have become the Mecca for prejudice and bigotry." And a GOP Senator, quoted anonymously by Politico, said rhetoric needed to be toned down, "There is a need for some reflection here -- what is too far now? What was too far when Oklahoma City happened is accepted now. There's been a desensitizing. These town halls and cable TV and talk radio, everybody's trying to outdo each other."
The motive of the shooter is still unclear, but for many political commentators Giffords is a victim of an increasingly polarized political climate that does not see the opposing side as the "loyal opposition" in keeping with democratic ideals, but as an implacable enemy. Political adversaries are increasingly portrayed as being not just wrong on policy, but threats to the very freedom of the nation. And the 2010 campaign saw references to guns as means to achieve political goals. In neighboring Nevada, the Republicans' Senate candidate and Tea Party favorite Sharron Angle spoke about "Second Amendment" remedies if her candidacy is not successful. She was not alone in invoking such imagery.
Giffords' district was one of the key seats focused on by the Tea Party movement this past election season in their cause to unseat Democrats. Giffords, a conservative Blue Dog Democrat just elected to her third term, was also one of Sarah Palin's "Take Back the 20": 20 Democratic members of the House identified by the political arm of the fmr. Alaska governor, SarahPAC, for electoral defeat in the midterms due to their health care vote. Giffords along with West Virginia Rep. Nick Rahall were the only two to secure reelection over Palin's supported candidates.
In the wake of the shooting that campaign has received scrutiny due to an image which has now acquired an unfortunate and unintentional foreboding: Sniper lens on the 20 Democrats were part of the ad created to promote "Take Back the 20". The lens were in white for most of the districts, but in red for those Democrats announcing their retirement as if signaling their termination. (See photo on left).
A SarahPAC aide, Rebecca Mansour, spoke to talk radio host Tammy Bruce: "We never ever, ever intended ti to be gun sights." She added, "It was simply crosshairs like you'd see on maps" and "it never occurred to us that anybody would consider it violent". Mansour concluded by saying that it was "repulsive" to politicize the shooting.
Sarah Palin frequently spoke to her supporters with the advice "Don't retreat, Instead - RELOAD!" and after the election boosted that her PAC defeated 18 of the 20 Democrats on her "bullseye" list. Such rhetoric, although not intending to incite violence, may no longer be acceptable now.
http://www.examiner.com/rnc-in-washington-dc/congresswoman-giffords-was-electoral-target-of-sarah-palin
Yeah, Sarah Palin will pay for this. Although it probably wasn't related to this, it points out how inappropriate something like this is.
ReplyDeleteNow Team Palin has to do damage control...